This is an interesting excerpt from the latest Scuttlebutt, and a reminder
of the difficulties we could all face if the need for MOB drill is ever
activated. Doesn't look good. All the more reason to stay on the boat.
Maybe this is a good reason why "sailing naked" is a good idea.

(
http://www.sailingscuttlebutt.com <http://www.sailingscuttlebutt.com/> )
Scuttlebutt is a digest of major yacht racing news, commentary, opinions,
features and dock talk . . . with a North American focus.
GUEST EDITORIAL - Chris Upton
In preparation for the Bermuda Race, we spent a Sunday afternoon sailing
around a life jacket in 4 knots of breeze. It took 20+ attempts for a crew
of eight. I decided to see what it would be like to be in the Gulf Stream.
The closest thing in Newport is the YMCA pool. The test tried to take into
account as many realities of being in the water as possible. I tried to
replicate being tired and worn out from boat handling. Dressed in full
foulies, sea boots, a life jacket, a t-shirt and shorts, I jumped in the
pool.
The first surprise was the fleece neck liner was letting the trapped air out
of my foulie jacket. As the air blew out it was replaced by close to 60
pounds of water. It was nearly impossible to swim more than a few strokes.
The life jacket did its job in keeping me afloat. Removing the life jacket
made swimming slightly easier, but not enough to save your life. Sea boots
full of water weigh too much to be able to kick your legs for swimming and
treading water. Removing them helped with swimming. It did not allow for
more distance covered. Treading water without the boots would be difficult
in a seaway. The drag from the foulies is too great. Removing the jacket and
pants was the only way to be able to swim for any distance. Just getting the
gear out of the pool was a challenge.
After spending 5 minutes in the water trying to swim, etc., getting out of
the pool required three tries. The pool has a freeboard of one foot.
The cotton t-shirt weighed over twenty pounds upon getting out. Pulling
yourself up 5 feet of freeboard without assistance is not going to happen.
The foul weather gear will add enough weight that crew along the rail will
be unlikely to get you up and out without putting themselves at risk.
Conclusions:
- Wear your life jacket before you think you need it.
- The boat has to come to the swimmer. You do not have any mobility in the
water. You will be tired from simply floating.
- Have a plan for getting a halyard onto the MOB. Putting a second person
in the water to help an unconscious or injured crewman only risks a second
crew and further limits the ability to recover anyone. The weight of the
water in your clothes is too much to lift alone.
- Wear boots that are large enough to be kicked off easily in the water.
- Chlorine will ruin your foulies. Don't try this with your good set.
Graham
"Directors' Special"
C34MkII (Oz Built) #615
Rhyll, Australia